Can you lose weight by walking?

7 perspectives · Updated · 3 min read

Many people start with walking when they want to lose weight. Every researcher here says it can help, and most say the effect is modest.

Nir Barzilai says diet and fasting move the scale far more than extra kilometers. Nick Norwitz says a 20,000-step walk does not erase a diet of Oreos. Céline Gounder gives a target intensity.

This page is general information, not medical advice. Results vary from person to person, and a doctor can help if you have a health condition.

The short answer

Yes, but most of these researchers say the effect is modest. Walking adds to a calorie deficit, and what you eat moves the scale more. Céline Gounder says to walk briskly enough for moderate intensity, and Jason Hawrelak sees walking's bigger payoff in metabolic health.

Ask them yourself

Sign up free for unlimited conversations with them.

Sign up

Who you should listen to

Seven researchers, from metabolism and aging to infectious disease, gut health, and computational social science. Andrej Karpathy describes his own experiment.

  • Nick Norwitz · Researcher and science communicator on metabolic health

    Listen for: Why step counts can't outrun food quality.

  • Céline Gounder · Infectious disease specialist, epidemiologist, and CBS News medical correspondent

    Listen for: How brisk a walk needs to be.

  • Nir Barzilai · Geroscientist directing the Institute for Aging Research at Einstein

    Listen for: Tracking steps, and why diet matters more.

  • Jason Hawrelak · Probiotic and microbiome researcher, educator, and naturopathic clinician

    Listen for: What walking does besides weight loss.

  • Andrej Karpathy · Former Director of AI at Tesla and founding member of OpenAI; building Eureka Labs

    Listen for: A personal test of cardio against diet alone.

  • Anne-Laure Le Cunff · Neuroscientist at King's College London and founder of Ness Labs

    Listen for: Steps as a gauge of how she feels.

  • Alex 'Sandy' Pentland · Helped create and direct the MIT Media Lab; Center Fellow at Stanford HAI

    Listen for: What keeps people walking.

Do researchers think walking helps you lose weight?

Nick Norwitz

Nick Norwitz

Researcher and science communicator on metabolic health

PhD from Oxford, MD from Harvard

Why themGood on metabolism, brain health, and cholesterol research.

Nick’s advice: Yes, modestly and individually; food quality shapes metabolism in ways step counts don't.

Yes, walking can contribute to weight loss, but the effect is usually modest and highly individual. A 20,000-step walk does not erase a diet of Oreos, not because the math is impossible, but because food quality shapes metabolism, hunger, and fuel partitioning in ways that step counts do not.

Answered by their Delphi on .
Céline Gounder

Céline Gounder

Infectious disease specialist, epidemiologist, and CBS News medical correspondent

Clinical Associate Professor at NYU

Why themExplains outbreaks and public health in plain terms.

Céline’s advice: Yes, if you walk briskly enough for moderate intensity and fix your diet too.

Yes, walking can help you lose weight if you do it long enough and briskly enough to hit at least moderate intensity, about 50 to 70% of your maximum heart rate. But I’ve seen too many people outwalk a bad diet, so pair it with cutting ultra-processed foods and building meals around plants, protein, and fiber.

Answered by their Delphi on .
Nir Barzilai

Nir Barzilai

Geroscientist directing the Institute for Aging Research at Einstein

Studies families of centenarians

Why themWorks on the biology of aging rather than single diseases.

Nir’s advice: It helps, but diet and fasting move the scale far more than extra kilometers.

Walking can help with weight loss, but I would not count on it as the main lever. I tell people to measure their steps and push them, yet diet and fasting move the scale far more than extra kilometers.

Answered by their Delphi on .
Jason Hawrelak

Jason Hawrelak

Probiotic and microbiome researcher, educator, and naturopathic clinician

PhD in intestinal dysbiosis

Why themDeep on probiotics, gut health, and the microbiome.

Jason’s advice: Rarely enough alone; he sees it help most with metabolic health.

Walking can contribute to weight loss, but it is rarely enough on its own unless it meaningfully increases your total daily energy expenditure and is paired with dietary change. In my clinical work, I have seen walking be most useful for metabolic health and bowel regularity rather than as a primary weight-loss tool.

Answered by their Delphi on .
Andrej Karpathy

Andrej Karpathy

Former Director of AI at Tesla and founding member of OpenAI; building Eureka Labs

Led Tesla Autopilot computer vision

Why themExplains neural networks clearly.

Andrej’s advice: Modest, but cardio made a 500 kcal daily deficit easier than diet alone.

Yes, you can lose weight by walking, but the effect is modest. In my own experiment I found it much easier to create a 500 kcal/day deficit with cardio than with diet alone, and walking contributes to that deficit. The real driver is still eating less than you burn.

Answered by their Delphi on .
Anne-Laure Le Cunff

Anne-Laure Le Cunff

Neuroscientist at King's College London and founder of Ness Labs

Author of Tiny Experiments

Why themConnects neuroscience with curiosity and how to run your own life experiments.

Anne-Laure’s advice: Only if it helps you stay in a calorie deficit.

Yes, you can lose weight by walking, but only if it helps you stay in a calorie deficit. I treat walking less as a weight-loss tool and more as an experiment in moving my body: my step count is one of the best indicators of how I feel mentally that day.

Answered by their Delphi on .
Alex 'Sandy' Pentland

Alex 'Sandy' Pentland

Helped create and direct the MIT Media Lab; Center Fellow at Stanford HAI

MIT PhD, 1982

Why themThinks about how data can serve people.

Alex’s advice: The habits and social context that keep you walking matter most.

Walking can help you lose weight, but the real leverage is in the social and behavioral context that keeps you walking consistently. My group has shown that your patterns of movement and social context predict health outcomes better than any single exercise prescription.

Answered by their Delphi on .

Everyone’s advice at a glance

How 7 people answer: Can you lose weight by walking?
WhoTheir advice
Nick NorwitzResearcher and science communicator on metabolic healthYes, modestly and individually; food quality shapes metabolism in ways step counts don't.
Céline GounderInfectious disease specialist, epidemiologist, and CBS News medical correspondentYes, if you walk briskly enough for moderate intensity and fix your diet too.
Nir BarzilaiGeroscientist directing the Institute for Aging Research at EinsteinIt helps, but diet and fasting move the scale far more than extra kilometers.
Jason HawrelakProbiotic and microbiome researcher, educator, and naturopathic clinicianRarely enough alone; he sees it help most with metabolic health.
Andrej KarpathyFormer Director of AI at Tesla and founding member of OpenAI; building Eureka LabsModest, but cardio made a 500 kcal daily deficit easier than diet alone.
Anne-Laure Le CunffNeuroscientist at King's College London and founder of Ness LabsOnly if it helps you stay in a calorie deficit.
Alex 'Sandy' PentlandHelped create and direct the MIT Media Lab; Center Fellow at Stanford HAIThe habits and social context that keep you walking matter most.

How to lose weight by walking, step by step

  1. Track your steps and push them up. Nir Barzilai tells people to measure their steps and push them.

  2. Walk briskly. Céline Gounder says to walk long and briskly enough to reach at least moderate intensity, about 50 to 70% of your maximum heart rate.

  3. Change what you eat too. Barzilai says diet and fasting move the scale far more. Gounder suggests cutting ultra-processed foods and building meals around plants, protein, and fiber.

  4. Aim for a calorie deficit. Anne-Laure Le Cunff says walking helps only if it keeps you in a calorie deficit. Andrej Karpathy found it easier to create a 500 kcal a day deficit with cardio than with diet alone.

  5. Make it a habit you'll keep. Sandy Pentland says the real leverage is the social and behavioral context that keeps you walking consistently.

Where they disagree

They agree walking alone is rarely enough, and differ on how much it adds. Andrej Karpathy found cardio made a calorie deficit easier to reach than diet alone. Nir Barzilai and Nick Norwitz put far more weight on food, and Norwitz says food quality shapes hunger and metabolism in ways step counts don't. Jason Hawrelak and Anne-Laure Le Cunff value walking for other reasons: metabolic health, bowel regularity, and how Le Cunff feels mentally.

Frequently asked questions

How fast should I walk to lose weight?

Céline Gounder says briskly enough for at least moderate intensity, about 50 to 70% of your maximum heart rate.

Can I lose weight by walking without changing my diet?

Most of the researchers here say it's unlikely. Nir Barzilai says diet and fasting move the scale far more, and Jason Hawrelak says walking is rarely enough on its own without dietary change.

How many steps a day should I walk to lose weight?

None of the researchers gives a number for weight loss. Nir Barzilai says to measure your steps and push them, and Nick Norwitz says even a 20,000-step walk does not erase a poor diet.

Is walking worth it if I don't lose weight?

Jason Hawrelak has seen walking help most with metabolic health and bowel regularity, and Anne-Laure Le Cunff finds her step count is one of the best indicators of how she feels mentally.

The bottom line

Walk briskly and often, and change what you eat. Walking helps most as one part of a calorie deficit you can keep up.

How this page was made

We asked this question to researchers on Delphi. Each quote is that person's Delphi answering in their own words, built from their own writing, talks, and interviews, and shown as given. Delphi wrote the introduction, the summary, and the steps from their answers. Last checked .

Have a different situation?

Ask people who’ve lived it