Top perspectives

  • Owen ZidarAnalyzed state business tax incentives and firm owners’ tax burden
    Professor of Economics and Public Affairs at Princeton UniversityFirm owners bear 40% tax burden2020 Sloan Research Fellowship recipient

    I would ask for the runner-up site, because comparing your town to the place that almost won is the cleanest way to see what the jobs actually buy.

  • Conor BaldwinLowell CFO since 2014
    City of LowellArchitect of $654M FY27 budgetImplemented LowellSTAT performance tracking

    I always ask what the deal costs per job, per year, and what happens if the company leaves early. In Lowell, we look at whether new growth in property taxes and state aid actually covers the forgone revenue, because a tax break that looks good on paper can still hollow out your levy capacity.

  • John MozenaExposed costly economic‑development subsidies as CEA president
    Authored Worst Economic Development Deal awardTestified to Michigan State Senate

    I spent two decades writing press releases that made these deals sound like wins, and the hardest question to answer is whether the jobs would exist without the subsidy. If you cannot get a straight, documented answer to that, you are not investing, you are guessing.

  • Dylan ParkerRock Island alderperson since 2017
    Commissioner at Bi-State Regional CommissionManaged $140M municipal budgetNegotiated $250k downtown agreement

    I look at whether the deal builds the kind of economy that will still be here when the jobs number is forgotten. In Rock Island we chased the Great White Whale for decades: $25 million sunk into an 11th Street Walmart site that flopped, a Sears hydro plant that never paid off, bonds we’re still paying. I ask what value chain the employer is climbing and whether our community is a commodity to them or a partner.

  • Betsey StevensonFormer chief economist
    Professor of Public Policy and Economics at University of MichiganBoard member, Lyft

    I would treat the tax break as a direct expenditure and demand the same proof you'd need to write a $50 million check: clawbacks if the jobs don't materialize, independent verification of the wage levels, and a real accounting of whether those 2,000 jobs are new or just relocated from the next town over.

  • Re-elected with 1,460 votesDeputy Mayor of Newbridge

    I’d want the deal written down in enforceable numbers before anything else: how many jobs are guaranteed, at what wage, for how long, and what happens to the tax break if they don’t deliver. In Newbridge I’ve watched too many projects stay on paper while the council is left carrying the cost, so I’d also ask what schools, GPs, buses, and housing the town needs before 2,000 extra workers arrive, and who pays for that.

  • Ulrika Gustafson, LL.M.Founder & Executive Advisor of Ulrika Gustafson Advisory
    Coaches Fortune 500 MDs, COOs, GCsAnalyzed 2,500 hours of coaching

    I look past the headline number. When I was a city manager, I always asked what happens if the jobs never show up, and whether the tax break is per actual hire or per promise. The real math is the clawback clause, the wage floor, and who pays if they leave in year three.

  • Philip PetersFounder of PEV Blockchain
    CMU econometrics fellow, 14 of 1,400CEO - CoFounder of CitiQuants Corporation

    I stopped trusting promised jobs the moment a Fortune 500 client counted every call-center seat as a job created; make them put the tax break in escrow and release it only when payroll taxes prove the hires happened.

  • Sinem CantürkAspire Leaders Program Participant at Aspire Institute
    Fellow at Aspire Institute

    I look past the headline jobs number and make them put the real cost on paper: what taxes we forfeit, what infrastructure we must build, and whether the 2,000 jobs are net new or just reshuffled from elsewhere.